[aidanorourke]

There has been another exchange of words between supporters of the proposed congestion charge, and opponents, most notably Peel Holdings, owners of the Trafford Centre and Manchester Ship Canal.

Sir Richard Leese, long time Leader of Manchester City Council has criticised Peel Holdings in connection with their 'No' campaign.

I attended a congestion charge debate at the Circle Club last autumn, and met both the directors of Peel Holdings and Sir Richard Leese.

Now Kelloggs have expressed their opposition to the scheme. Three Greater Manchester local authorities, Stockport, Trafford and Bury have voted against the proposals. The remaining seven are in favour. If another authority withdraws its support, then a local referendum may follow.

I personally am against the current proposals, mainly due to the method of charging - a 'dumb' flat rate charge based on boundaries. I would be in favour of a 'smart' charge, maybe using GPS technology, that is fine-tuned and doesn't discriminate geographically.

Some time in spring 2008 we should find out if the Manchester bid has been successful.

Are you in favour of the congestion charge or against? Will it have a devastating effect on the economy of the Manchester area, as Peel Holdings suggest, or is it the only option for sustainable transport in the local area