|
THE FIRST THING WE SEE as we walk from Oldham St are the public toilets,
the only new facility to be introduced to Piccadilly Gardens in many
years. Otherwise this area is dirty, dingy and run-down.
Your proposal for this spot is a set of walk-through fountains set
in an oval-shaped enclosure with a sort of hump-back footbridge. I find
this idea highly inappropriate for this location, particularly in view
of the the local climate.
It seems amazing and ironic that in a city reputed by popular myth
to be rainy, that you want to add to this perceived rainfall by artificial
means. A feature such as this will only be appreciated during hot, sunny
weather, particularly by youths who have nowhere else to splash about
due to Manchester's appalling lack of outdoor water facilities. At other
times of the year, the area will I'm sure soon start to collect discarded
paper, drink cans and other rubbish.

Piccadilly - Mosley
St Market St corner
Here at the top end of Piccadilly we can see the wide open area created
by the Metrolink lines. You propose a "bosque" for this area.
Most people won't know what this is. You didn't explain it in your exhibition
- I had to look it up in the dictionary. It means "wood" however
I understand that the proposed Piccadilly "bosque" is a row
of small trees in pots. However, I'm still not entirely sure what you're
proposing, but whatever it is, it looks to be seriously out of character
with the surrounding area and I don't like it.

Piccadilly Mosley
St Market St corner
We can see from the photos above and right that this part of Piccadilly
has some very beautiful buildings, with a strongly 1930's neo-classical
character - The Debenhams building, the former cinema right and the
landscaping of the Gardens all date from around this time or just before.
The statues are all of 19th century design. I feel very strongly that
any new development should have a character which is in harmony with
this, unlike your proposal, aptly described by someone as a sort of
"nouvelle cuisine international style", a late 90's architectural
fashion which seems to be taking over many other parts of Manchester
at the moment. The oval-based, brushed-steel, minimalist, "extra-terrestrial"
look may suit Tokyo, Hulme Park or the set of a sci-fi movie, but not
Piccadilly.
I would propose a larger Piccadilly Gardens in "contemporary classical"
style, extending beyond the Peel statue and into the area occupied by
the tram lines on the left. A design example which springs to mind are
the gates in honour of the Queen Mother, Hyde Park Corner, London. Come
to think of it, how would they restore and renovate St James's Park
in London? That's how we should redesign Piccadilly Gardens in Manchester.
And there's nothing wrong with emulating London, after all, that's where
the name 'Piccadilly' came from.
By the way, one of the points left undecided in the plan was the fate
of the statues, including the Peel Statue and the Wellington Statue.
They should be left exactly where they have stood for nearly a century
and a half, and the Gardens should be extended beyond and round them.
In picture (right) we can see the remains of the original wall dating
from the 19th century or before. Not many people are aware that this
used to be the top end of George Street, and that across the street,
a triangular shaped block of buildings stood where the tram lines are
now. It was destroyed in the Blitz, leading to the enlargement of Piccadilly
into the broad impressive space it is today.
Ironic, then, that 60 years later you plan to construct a building
at the opposite end of Piccadilly which will reduce its size to smaller
than in was pre 1940. We'll come to this in a moment.

Metrolink lines under
construction 1991
One of the problems of Piccadilly Gardens is the imbalance created
by the construction of the Metrolink lines in 1991 and 92. In the picture
above we can see how the whole of the top end of Piccadilly, previously
occupied by bus stands, is taken up by tram lines and is effectively
wasted. In fact, Piccadilly should have been remodelled at the same
time the Metrolink was put in.
.
Parker St bus station
& Metrolink tram lines
Let's walk over to Piccadilly Plaza - this area has for a long time
been run-down. You propose to improve the quality of building, changing
the overhang along Parker St, upgrading the shop windows and improving
the lighting- I broadly approve of these plans.
What I'm not so keen on is the idea, as part of the plan to redevelop
Piccadilly Plaza, to demolish Bernard House. If we're going to keep
Piccadilly Plaza, then let's keep is as much as possible to the original
design.

Piccadilly Plaza,
Parker St bus station
Let's cross over into Piccadilly Gardens. People often
say the gardens are a run-down no-go area at night, and this is true,
but on sunny days, many people enjoy going there, as can be seen in
the pictures on the right. The sunken gardens are a familiar and well-loved
spot in Manchester city centre and should in my opinion be kept.

Piccadilly Gardens
central area
I strongly disapprove of the proposed "pavilion"
with its curved concete wall dividing the gardens from the buses. Again,
it is out of character with the area, and the use of concrete has been
proven to be an unattractive building material in our climate. Such
a building may look great in downtown Tokyo, but not in the centre of
Manchester. Anyway, I don't think it's necessary to divide the buses
from the Gardens in this way.
We can see in the panorama above that in fact the main
explanation of why the Gardens are less pleasant than they should be
is not "lack of a walk-through fountain" or "outmoded,
unfashionable layout", but the fact that you, Manchester City
Council, have failed to maintain them properly for the past 7 years
or so. If the Gardens had been given at the minimum repair and maintenance,
they would not be in the state they are in now.

Piccadilly sunken
gardens
In fact, I find Piccadilly Gardens rather pleasant, as
can be seen in the picture above - Have Piccadilly Gardens really
deteriorated so far beyond the point of no return that they should now
be condemned, bulldozed and built over?

Piccadilly Gardens
corner of Portland St, Parker St (left) and Aytoun St (right)
Coming down to the Portland Street end of Piccadilly Gardens,
we can see in this picture the place where the proposed building would
stand.
Do you really think that the people of Manchester are
overwhelmingly in favour of a building on the spot currently occupied
by the trees? I have tried very crudely to superimpose a structure on
the proposed spot. You haven't specified the design, so this is the
best I can do. But whatever the design, it's clear that the area is
better left a green open space.

Piccadilly Gardens
Porlant St - rough sketch of how a building might look
240 years ago, Sir Oswald Mosley donated the land which
is now Piccadilly for the building of a new infirmary on condition that
it would always be kept for public use (Guide Across Manchester by Philip
Atkins, page 22). The Infirmary was demolished in the 1900's, and various
plans for buildings were dropped in favour of simply leaving the site
a green, open space.
It is outrageous that Manchester City Council should
now decide, behind closed doors, to sell off this green space in the
heart of the city for construction. Leave my Piccadilly Gardens alone!
|
|
View (above)
from Queen Victoria statue (left) Wellington Statue (right)
|
|
As we walk by the statue of Wellington and Queen Victoria, we are again
struck by the air of terminal neglect, and the tackiness of the surroundings.
As I've stated previously, this didn't just happen of its own accord
- it has happened because Manchester City Council has neglected to
repair and maintain the area properly. But the fact that you have neglected
the area is not a sufficient reason to bulldoze it and put something
inappropriate in its place.
I note that horticultural gardens are planned for either side of the
statue of Queen Victoria. Again, my reaction is that these would be
suitable for an out-of-town location, but not here in the heart of the
city. Walk-through fountains, "bosque", concrete pavilion,
horticultural gardens - it seems the designers have gone overboard with
gimmicky ideas.
A balanced, uncontroversial and less costly redevelopment scheme,
which doesn't require sacrificing part of Piccadilly Gardens for construction,
would be a far better solution and, I think, more in keeping with the
wishes of the people of Manchester, and of the many visitors who come
to our city.
Arriving back at our starting point, we've seen much to give cause
for concern, but Piccadilly has the potential to be restored to what
it was until recently - and better - a spacious, pleasant and traditional
style garden in the heart of the city.

Manchester City Council, you have done some very good work in the redevelopment
of the city centre in recent years. You appear to have learned your
lesson from projects such as the Market St obelisk, the fountains in
Brazennose Square and St Ann's Square, the Arndale Centre exterior,
the demolition of York House, the Hulme Crescents, Piccadilly Plaza,
and many other post-war examples of bad city planning.
However, this case may cap the lot of them if it ever goes ahead. You
must concede that if your plans don't have the approval of local people
and other interested parties - and I believe they don't - then you must
abandon them and start again.
Yours faithfully,
Aidan O'Rourke
|