This is an archived website and is no longer updated. Click here to go to the www.aidan.co.uk home page
EWM Home Page | Aidan O'Rourke on Twitter and Facebook | Contact
READER MESSAGES Late June / Early July 2001 (Early June)

Name: Pauline
E-Mail: paulinesutcliffe@zfree.co.nz
Website:
From or connections with: Hulme (1930's), Birchvale (New Mills), Wythenshawe, Timperley
Present Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Subject: What a wonderful web site, Aidan
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
Congratulations on a great site. We are most fortunate to be able to bring up Manchester historically and today which evokes all sorts of memories. The photos are top class and I find the memories of Mancunians fascinating to read. Yes Manchester is a great city, not perfect, and our city fathers have not always got it right. I'll look forward to seeing the changes in Piccadilly some day, hopefully. I used to work at the telephone exchange in Chapel Street and then transferred to Piccadilly in the 1950's. Mum, in the 1920's worked at Marks and Spencers and later at Lewiss'. Such a shame it is not there anymore. I look forward to receiving your newsletters. TTFN

Yes, a shame about Lewis's - it's like London without Selfridges. Marks & Spencer is still there, now its new building, though it is reducing its floor space by half. The city is changing all the time - the building above, formerly known as Eagle Star House, has now disappeared - but hopefully the spirit of Manchester will continue always.


Name: IRENE MOORES nee WHITE
E-Mail: alan.moores@virgin.net
Website:
From or connections with: Chorlton on Medlock, Chorlton cum Hardy, Harpurhey
Present Location: NORTH WALES
Subject: QUEEN VICTORIA, HIGH STREET BATHS, ST THOMAS'S
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan,
I enjoyed this site immensely. I remember going to High Street (Victoria) Baths, when I was a child. Myself and friends Geraldine Harvey, Linda Lee, Madonaa Kashen, Helen Hargreaves et al used to haunt the place every summer holidays. It cost 6d to get in, as I recall.
Recently I revisted Manchester and found St. Thomas's church on Ardwick Green still in beautiful condition, this is where my mother (Llewela) Margaret White nee Williams and her brothers Bill and Jo and sister Bette went to school in the 1920s, I was surprised to find the school rooms at the rear of the church in such an extremely run down condition.
My connection with Harpurhey is the area where I was sent to school, on Monsall Road - Harpurhey Technical High School, a brand new school in the 1960s. I had a free bus pass because I travelled over 3 miles to get there. Is there anyone out there with the original school photograph which was taken in our first year that I could have a copy of please?
Cheerio, Irene.

PS: I just remembered this too late after sending the last message.
Once after a student rag someone had painted giant footprints leading from Queen Victoria's statue down to the ladies toilets.

Thank you very much for your message - Victoria Baths were closed by Manchester City Council in 1993. Today the Victoria Baths Trust are aiming to re-open the baths in a couple of years as a Healthy Living Centre. They have the full support of the present city council. I had a purple bus pass to get from Stockport to my school Xaverian College in Victoria Park. Yes, St Thomas's Church on Ardwick Green is in good condition. The area around it is run down but redevelopment is progressing.



Name: Eveline Sommerhalder
E-Mail: jsommerhalder@home.com
Website:
From or connections with: Harpurhey
Present Location: Kingston,Ontario,Canada
Subject: Books on old Lancs
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
Have been reading the site now for 2 years and want to thank you for such a wonderful job. I seem to recall there was a section on Mancunian where it was possible to order books on Manchester and area but I can no longer find it. I have a book called Figures in a Bygone Landscape by Don Haworth published in 1986 about his childhood in Lancashire and I think I ordered it from the MEN. Some ex-lancs people are asking where they can get this book. Can you help?
Many thanks Eveline

One of the best places to locate books online is the Amazon.co.uk website. Just do a search for the title you're looking for, and if it's available, you should find it. I prefer to go to bookshops and browse before I buy, especially when buying books of photographs. If you're outside the UK, that's going to be difficult, so see if you can locate it online. Thanks for your message.


Name: Mike Clarke
E-Mail: www.budotasmania@ausi.com
Website:
From or connections with: C-on-M and Fallowfield
Present Location: Launceston,Tasmania.
Subject: Nostalgia
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
I hope this finds you and yours fit and well.I just thought I'd drop you a line having read the latest news reports elswhere in the web-site.I have to say that life in Manchester (well,parts of it), seems to be an endless round of shoot-outs and gang related killings.
I know what it's like to be a 'bad-lad' on the streets,but 'Murder',well thats something else.Is every English city like this these days,or is it just Manchester ? I'm begining to think that my old home town is best remembered as it was when I left it.Places like Longsight, Rusholme, Moss Side and Hulme,were all places to be carefull in,but no one expected to be shot by a kid with a machine-gun !
Forget the fuss over Piccadilly (?),what on earth are the city leaders doing about the guns ??? And how come the people are more bothered about the loss of their gardens,than the loss of their kids ?From the distance of my home in Tasmania I guess it's easy for me to have a go at the situation in Manchester,and maybe it's only through nostalgia that I even want to know how things are in the city ? But it must be clear to those in charge that something (other than talk) has to be done.No doubt something will be done for a while when the Commonwealth Games hit town,but I'm talking about REAL solutions.After all,is'nt that what political leaders are so well paid for,to provide solutions to problems that arise in society.
A friend of mine who recently returned from a trip to England (not Manchester), commented that he had never seen so many people 'struggling' to live a normal life. It brought back the feelings I had almost twenty years ago when I left.If you did a survey of ex-pats like me who click on to your page regularly, I think you would find that while its fantastic to return home vie the net, the thought of 'living' in Manchester again would be a big "No thanks". And thats sad.
Manchester was and still is a great place, but as I get older, I've come to realize it looks much better the longer I stay away.
Best regards,
Mike Clarke.

The question of how we perceive our home city when we're no longer living in it is of central importance. When I lived in the Middle East, I had an increasing desire to be a part of my home city again, especially in the aftermath of the IRA bomb of June 1996. Luckily I returned the month after and started doing Eyewitness in Manchester the following January. When you're abroad, it's difficult to keep an up to date and accurate picture of home. You have only your memories and perhaps my photographs. Reading the news you get a distorted picture of life here, as it tends to focus on the abnormal, i.e. what's newsworthy. I live in inner city Manchester, but I don't have the impression that a 'gun war' is going on around me. In comparison to cities in the United States, gun-related crime is relatively unusual. Speaking personally I'd much rather be in the UK than other places I've lived in, and the only place in the UK I want to live is my home city of Manchester.


Name: Martin Baird
E-Mail: m.baird2@ntlworld.com
Website:
From or connections with: Prestwich & radcliffe
Present Location:
Subject: Piccadilly Gardens
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan,just been reading about Piccadilly Gardens, only one word sums up my thoughts of the councillors who have let this happen,
BARBARIANS,
What the IRA could not do, the council & central government succeed in doing.
Martin Baird
Redcar & Cleveland

Well, let's not get too emotive about this - councillors are only human, they make mistakes like all of us. Lets keep the criticisms rational and constructive. Personally I think it's the local government system that's at fault, rather than individuals. The local authorities in the Manchester area should come together to form one mega-city which would be one of the largest in Europe and perhaps one of the most prosperous. Then the city fathers wouldn't feel obliged to sell off land for office space in order to fund their development plans. But who knows, maybe I'm wrong. Maybe in 10 years time tourists will flock to the new Piccadilly as they do to Piccadilly Circus in London - I doubt it, but let's wait and see.


Name: Cliff Hughes
E-Mail: chughes7@sympatico.ca
Website:
From or connections with:
Present Location: Ontario Canada
Subject: Reminiscences of times in Manchester
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
I have very fond memories of Manchester from the 1930s. I was born in North Wales but I guess the 30s being what they were Dad moved to Manchester to look for work.
I started school at the age of three at Plymouth Grove school in Longsight I think. We lived in Park Avenue which must have been close. I can also remember going to cinemas called the Kings, Queens and the Shaftbury.
Many happy hours were spent on the rowing boats at Platt Fields park and the Speedway at Belle View.
The maternal side of my family have had strong connections with some Manchester pubs. Relations of mine were Licensees at one time or another of the Waggon & Horses at Peel Green,The Dolphin(I don't remember where that was), The Stretford Hotel on Stretford Road not far from a store called Paulden's, this was run by Bill Meredith who played soccer and was my mother's Uncle by marriage. I have been in ManCity's board room having been taken there by Mr Meredith.
I was rescued from my bedroom by a policeman in Park avenue when the house next door had some kind of a fire.I also have very fond memories of visiting the Manchester Co-oP store in Downing St. at Christmas time.
The buses and the trams were very exciting to me.
Please excuse my deluge of nostalgia, these times are very dear to me as my mother was alive then and life was joyful and full of exciting things to do and learn. My memories are such that manchester is the most exciting city I have lived in todate, and I've lived in a quite few.
I shall read your paper from now on because I find it so interesting and vibrant.
Regards
Cliff Hughes

Some great reminiscences there - It's so important to cherish the good things you remember, and to share them with family, friends and the world via the Internet. The Manchester Co-Op on Downing St and Paulden's on Stretford Road?. I regularly drive up and down both these roads but I have no idea of where either of these stores were located. I must pay a visit to the Central Library Local Studies Unit and have another look at their photo collection. Thanks for your message and kind comments.


Name: Gary
E-Mail: gs2@bigfoot.com
Website:
From or connections with:
Present Location: Manchester
Subject: Odd
EWM Photo:
GARY
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
I find your attitude towards gay men a little odd sometimes and, like many straight men, you seem a little obsessed with the sexual aspects.
Bikers wear leather and have tattoos, women wear low cut dresses and short skirts - all in the name of appearing sexually attractive. Would you censor these 'Manchester' images for your class? So why censor the gay image?
Also I note that you don't mention removing the Boddingtons image from the selection of photographs that you would present to children.
Personally I think alcohol is far more of a worry as far as young people are concerned.
If a child is gay (and I was attracted to other boys at age 5), then there is no way they can change that. However, there is choice over whether they end up drinking or not and I don't think it is good to encourage it.
But, then again, you often refer to 'pints' and 'pubs' so it is clear that you think that is OK... :-)
This is not meant to be an attack on you or anything. I love your site. I just hope to make you think.
GARY

I was browsing through a selection of Manchester publicity photographs and in amongst the architectural shots and streets scenes there was a man in leather gear with studs, piercings, tattoos etc. Personally I found it an extremely negative image, as I can't stand the 'S&M' look whoever is wearing it whether gay or straight male or female. I suppose that's what I really wanted to say. Thanks for your contribution and your positive comments about my website.


Name: Mike Jenkins
E-Mail: Mike@jenkins.eurobell.co.uk
Website:
From or connections with: Irlam
Present Location: Crawley, West Sussex.
Subject: Irlam Cemetery
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
I'm not sure if you and your readers could help me or not, but recently I started to compile my family tree and one response in particular moved my attention to Irlam. In a email received from a relative she wrote "I used to chat to our Nan a lot about the past, where she lived etc. She was born on 13.1.1891. She lived at Irlam and played on Chat moss. Her granddad has a special grave near the gate to the church commemorating him for his pioneering days in North Africa.". Now I realise that this isn't much, but would any of your readers know if there is a such a grave fitting this description in Irlam, and if so, where can it be found (I assume there must be several churches) She also mentions that this was "her granddad" in which case the Name would be "Melling", but as she mentions North Africa‚ it could well be she's confused and in fact the name is "Jenkins" who I know drove the first Steam Engine in Egypt.
Regards Mike Jenkins

I think a little research is needed to find out the answer to your question -but maybe someone out there has the answer - unfortunately I can't provide it! Hope you find the information you're looking for - let me know if you do!


Name: helen turner
E-Mail: hturner@plymouth.ac.uk
Website: www.plymouth.ac.uk
From or connections with: withington (born) lived until '67 in stockton street moss side
Present Location: exmouth in sunny devon
Subject: piccadily gardens
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
Not happy to learn of the demise of piccadilly gardens, I remember we office friends used to meet in the gardens of a lunchtime when I worked at Sparrow Harwicks on London Road in the mid 60's. other girl friends worked at SJ Cook & Watts (I think) now the Britannia Hotel.
helent

The 50's and 60's were the golden era of Piccadilly Gardens. I don't think the new gardens will ever recapture that spirit of quintessential Manchester, but maybe I'm wrong. We'll know by summer 2002

 


Name: Theresa Casey-Panko
E-Mail: degnan@sympatico.ca
Website:
From or connections with: Hulme
Present Location: Brantford, Ontario Canada
Subject: memories of childhood
EWM Photo:
http://www.aidan.co.uk/eyewitness-in-manchester/ic11/21mx.jpg
Reader Message: Dear Aidan, hello. My name is Theresa and I live in Canada. I have been looking for my roots in Manchester. I was excited to see pictures of where I lived as a child. I have not been back there since 1966, and have missed it. I am now trying to bring the past into the present for myself. I have just started to read your articles, and I am already thrilled by what I see. My father use to manage two pubs before we came to Canada. My family use to live on Marple Street, Hulme before moving to the pub just up the street. It was called "The Great Eastern". That was in the late 50's to early 60's. Then we moved downtown Manchester and lived in the pub called "The Mechanic Arms". We left there in 1966. Although, I was not yet ten years of age, I can still remember places like Piccidilly. I do have a hard time with the idea that this beautiful place is being torned apart for the purpose of "progress". There are many fond memories of the Gardens. It is such a shame. Hopefully, the people of Manchester and other areas can still find some comfort with such a loss.
Until another time, I will keep looking at your pictures. Hope to see more of the "old neighbourhood".
Sincerely,
Theresa Casey-Panko

As I say, let's wait and see but I'm not encouraged by the construction work I've witnessed recently when getting on and off the bus in and around Piccadilly. Hulme is developing very well thanks to the millions of pounds of funds which have been invested in it. It's a pity that funding on this scale isn't available for every run-down area of Manchester. Interesting your choice of picture - I'd forgotten about that one completely - it's a series of plaques fixed into the ground documenting the history of Hulme. I captured just a small selection of them. Yes, I hope to bring more photographs of the 'old neighbourhood' now one of Manchester's newest, in future updates.



Name: josh gold
E-Mail: jgold@andersonkill.com
Website:
From or connections with: i visited manchester for the first time this year and really enjoyed it.
Present Location: NYC, U.S.A
Subject: history of salford lads club
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
I was curious as to whether you know any of the history of the Salford Lads Club. I was able to find on the Internet a picture of the interior of the gym dating from 1909. I was curious to know when it was originally built and the relationship it has to the surrounding row houses on Coronation street. I saw a music video from the 1980s that was shot there and the entire neighborhood looked shut down and in disrepair. When i visited Manchester and Salford for the first time this year, I noticed that Coronation St. look revitalized and was home to many, many families. I was wondering if you could give me a very brief overview of the history of the lads club and surrounding neighborhood if it is not too much trouble.
Thank you,
josh

The video you saw was the one by Morrissey of The Smiths. I don't have any information on Salford Lads Club at the moment - can anyone help?


Name: Correia, Joás
E-Mail:
Website:
From or connections with:
Present Location:
Subject:
EWM Photo:
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
My name is Correia. I was born in Brazil, State of Bahia, Ipiaú city.I am so happy because I am talking with you. I should be like to know your contry, specialty your city "Manchester". I must to say you,my english is not very good, but I want to learn more. Thank you by this oportunity and I hope to be there for some days.
Thank you,
Correia, Joás Jose
e-mail joáscorreia zip.mail.com.br

Very nice to hear from you. I have met quite a lot of Brazilian people here in Manchester - either working or studying. We recently had a taste of Brazil in Manchester during the X.Trax street festival when this dance troupe made a procession through the city centre. Manchester is very different to Brazil, but thanks to the Internet, we can meet online and share our thoughts.


Name: beverley
E-Mail: b.davis@lanmore.ac.uk
Website:
From or connections with: na
Present Location: morecambe
Subject: granada studios
EWM Photo: when will Granada studios re-open, we have been promising our daughter for a year that we would visit and had planned to go next week !!

I understand Granada Studios Tour has closed permanently to the general public. This is a pity as it was a major tourist attraction (though I found it disappointing when I visited in 1987). There are plenty of other attractions in Manchester city centre to take your daughter to see - how about the Printworks entertainment centre?


Name: Margaret
E-Mail: scharti@freesurf.ch
Website:
From or connections with: Hulme Area
Present Location: Zürich, Switzerland
Subject: Maps or directions of old Hulme
EWM Photo: unfortunately have none
Reader Message: Dear Aidan
I was born in Hulme but left quite young to live in Denton. Now married and living in Switzerland over 30 years.
Have been trying to receive information about Hulme maybe old maps,etc.
Unfortunately have no family left in Manchester. Can you help?
Congratulations on this page, it seems there is a lot of interest in Manchester.
I shall be visiting Manchester in August, if you cannot help please give me details of how I can get hold of this
information.
Many thanks and keep up this wonderful page.

The best place to find information on Hulme is at the Local Studies Unit in Manchester Central Library. They have a photo collection which can be accessed using computer terminals, and they also have a large collection of books, newspaper cuttings and other material. I hope to feature Hulme - the present day Hulme - in future.


Name: Andrew Theokas
E-Mail: atheokas@rcn.com
Website:
From or connections with: Rusholme
Present Location: Boston, Massachusetts
Subject: Congratulations and Thank you
EWM Photo: http://www.aidan.co.uk/eyewitness-in-manchester/ic3/64.jpg
Reader Message: Dear Aidan,
I think you must know by now that your web site and its images of Manchester serves to stir fond memories of Manchester for former Mancunians throughout the world.
I spent five years at the University and yes it was drab, dank, damp, dull and dour there in the late seventies. I loved it. Somehow the city had an authenticity, a hard bitten reality that made you feel an alive participant, rather than as another accessory on some glamorous boulevard inhabited by flaneurs and poseurs.
For its former inhabitants it is a city with a nagging magnetism, and whenever we return, we feel we are coming home.
Thank you for your works.

I was active in Manchester during the late 70's - your description is very accurate. But what of the flaneurs and poseurs - are you referring to your present location or to what Manchester has become? Thanks for a very well-written and thought-provoking contribution.

 

Page 1 | Page 2 | EWM HOME PAGE

Eyewitness in Manchester Home Page | Aidan O'Rourke on Twitter and Facebook | Contact