AIDAN O’ROURKE

Tutor & Digital Journalist   AidanEyewitness  AidanTutor

Please subscribe to my AidanEyewitness YouTube channel
  • Home page
  • Photo walks & tuition
    • Liverpool Photo Walk
    • Manchester Photo Walk
  • Online language classes
  • Articles / blog posts

Review: “Do Not Refreeze” exhibition of East German photography 2007

2021-01-16 By Aidan O'Rourke

Do Not Refreeze was an exhibition at the Cornerhouse Manchester that was on in 2007. I wrote an article about it, uploaded on the 26th of April 2007. It went offline due to technical issues with my legacy aidan.co.uk website. After receiving a request to see the article, I imported it and the photos into my main aidan.co.uk WordPress site. Since 2007 I have returned to teaching German and it is now my main career alongside producing multilingual articles, podcasts and videos for my AidanEyewitness YouTube channel. The Cornerhouse closed in 2015 and the nearby HOME became Manchester’s premier combined centre for cinema, theatre and art. Below is the article I wrote back in 2007. The photos are as powerful as ever. And I am going to recommend this article to my many German language students. Many thanks to Julian Pardo for requesting to see the article.

Do Not Refreeze is an exhibition of photographs by East German photographers from the 1950s to the 1980s. It’s a big exhibition, laid out on three floors with a huge variety of images. It takes you on a journey through the changing cityscapes of the GDR, and the people who inhabited that mostly grey and decrepit country. Despite the restrictions, life behind the Berlin Wall could be surprisingly rich, though not in a material sense. That’s the message we get from this remarkable and fascinating exhibition.

The first level of the exhibition takes us into the GDR during the 1950s. The first and only socialist state on German soil was founded in 1949, but it continued to be referred to by many as ‘the Zone’, short for Soviet Zone of Occupation, for many years after.

In the first photos by Arno Fischer (28 years old in 1955) we see people standing in bombed out buildings with pockmarked facades, a familiar theme of photography in Europe in the years just after the war. But in East Germany the ruins survived into the 1950s and beyond, often standing side by side with new construction.

Do Not Refreeze Exhibition Esat Berlin Tatra car by Arno Fischer

In another image by Arno Fischer, a Tatra car, preferred transport of the communist elite of that time, is pictured on an empty Strausberger Platz, just off Karl-Marx-Allee in East Berlin. It’s surrounded by recently built Soviet-style residential blocks.

Cars are a recurring theme and mark the passage of time.

Like other photographers in the exhibition, Arno Fischer focuses on individuals within crowd scenes. Their expressions give a clue as to what people really about their situation, especially in the two photographs at the funeral of Wilhelm Pieck in 1960.

Do Not Refreeze Exhibition Esat Berlin Wilhelm Pieck by Arno FischerFuneral of Wilhelm Pieck 1960 photo by Arno Fischer

In the GDR, all arts were subject to rigid guidelines. Socialist Realism was the only permitted style. Workers and peasants were to be depicted heroically defending and supporting the communist state and its authoritarian leaders.

Photography was however regarded as an applied art and not as prestigious as painting or sculpture. For this reason, photographers were able to achieve a much greater degree of realism and creative independence than their colleagues working in other media.

All of the photographers featured in this exhibition attended the Hochschule für Grafik und Buchkunst in Leipzig. It was the only place in the GDR where it was possible to study photography and it continues to be an important institution today. One of the photographers featured in the exhibition, Erasmus Schröter, teaches photography there.

Arno Fischer’s striking portrait of John Heartfield, whose subversive pro-communist posters and paintings created a stir in the Weimar Republic three decades earlier, is another gem of the exhibition. Heartfield settled in the GDR after the war, but looking at his face we can only speculate on what he thought of his adopted country.

Arno Fischer photographed Marlene Dietrich in Leningrad 1964 as well as workers in Ecuatorial Guinea, who are given the stark monochrome ‘GDR’ treatment.

The GDR at the time had interests and projects in various parts of the world. Photographers had to be in favour with the authorities in order to be allowed to travel to ‘non-Socialist’ parts of the world.

Sibylle Bergemann’s views of East Berlin, the Soviet Union and a wintry Sellin on the Baltic are haunting. Startlingly she also has a photograph from Hollywood – it’s a half derelict looking house, perhaps part of a film lot.

Another recurring theme in this exhibition is the enigmatic quality of many of the photos, which raise more questions than they answer. There is no description or background information with any of the images, just a title. The intention is for people to look and form their own impressions. Background information is available in the book to accompany the exhibition (see cover image upper left).

The photography of East Germany is mostly unknown in the UK, but if we can speak of an archetypal image, it’s of decrepit half derelict buildings and empty streets with lone figures and parked Trabants. This may have been the sad reality that people had to live through for 40 years but it makes an ideal photographic subject for black and white photography.

Some of Sibylle Bergemann’s photos fulfil this archetype and they are superbly crafted and fascinating to look at.

Do Not Refreeze exhibition GDR East Berlin Palast der Republik S Bergemann 1978
Berlin Palace of the Republic 1978 Photo by Sibylle Bergemann

In her ‘Berlin Palace of the Republic’, we return to the theme of faces within a crowd. Looking at the ceiling lamps in the upper part of the picture we can see why people called it ‘Erichs Lampenladen’ or ‘Erich’s lamp shop’.

Under the lamps, we see the backs of people looking down over a balcony. Our eyes are drawn to the child in the lower right. What is that child doing now?

I went into that building many times on my visits to East Berlin, and in the restaurants there, ate delicious and very cheap meals often with Soviet-influenced names.

That’s also a question we ask of the signature image of a pale-faced blond-haired 10-year-old girl. The picture is entitled ‘Kirsten Hoppenrade’ and also appears on the cover of the catalogue (upper left).

To me it doesn’t really sum up the content of the exhibition, but it is a haunting image that should capture the attention of a wide audience and draw them in.

Some images from the Communist East can defy expectations. This is the case of the fashion-style images of women by the river in east Berlin taken in the 80s. This could almost be Paris.

These images taken by Sibylle Bergemann appeared in the GDR fashion magazine, also coincidentally named Sibylle.

The exhibition contains much that is unexpected and perhaps the most surprising thing of all is that these images by virtually unknown photographers are of a standard equal to the best photographers of the 20th century. Forgotten and ignored for decades, they can now be seen in this exhibition.

We continue on Level 2 with images by Evelyn Richter (30 years old in 1960)

Her photos carve out a sharp and grainy monochrome vision of her homeland. Her technical and creative powers are evident from the first glance.

At Plänterwald Station, East Berlin we can just see the blocks of flats through the open doors of one of the 1930s style suburban railway trains that were a signature of Berlin until quite recently. Another image of hers taken at Plänterwald Station shows just the blocks of flats which have a monolithic quality.

Do Not Refreeze Exhibition Magdeburg by E Richter

Magdeburg 1968 Photo by Evelyn Richter

The same is true of her startling image of tenement blocks in Magdeburg seen over empty ground and tramlines. These are familiar images of the east: grim, grainy and haunting.

But by contrast, the photo of the River Spree in East Berlin by Museum Island has a Parisian quality, softened by the mist. An element of irony is provided by the passing barge whose title is ‘Traumland’ or Dreamland. What were the East Berliners dreaming of? Paris maybe?

In many of Evelyn Richter’s photos, there is a picture within a picture, giving an extra dimension of meaning to the image.

Ursula Arnold (born 1929) presents us with candid images of people within the streetscape of 1950s Leipzig. There is an old woman bent over and shadowy staircase, a couple just married and celebrating within a cobbled street overlooked by crumbling tenement facades. Children are pictured playing on a similar street, and here I’m reminded of the street photos of Shirley Baker taken in Salford during the 1960s.

The street scenes are a stark reminder of how the East was and now mostly no longer looks today.

Cars and other forms of transport are a focal point and give some clues as to when the photos were taken, though many vehicles were kept running for years so dating a picture can be difficult. The clapped out three-wheeled vehicle in Rykestrasse looks like something from another age. There are decrepit trams, vans, and other vehicles it’s now very difficult to put a name to. We are looking at a lost world, which thank goodness, these photographers have captured for posterity.

In more of Ursula Arnold’s photos, we return to the theme of faces within a crowd, especially those of children. The little boy with the balloon, May 1965 stands out.

A prominent feature of Ostalgie or nostalgia for the GDR is the memory of brand names a few of which are visible in some of the photos.

Helga Paris (born 1938) continues the familiar theme of East Germans portrayed in their environment. Despite the decrepitude of the surroundings, the individuality and humanity of the people shine through.

As a photographer of street scenes myself, I am irresistibly drawn to the images of the empty, ghostly streets of the east, particularly the unnamed street in Halle, devoid of anything apart from three figures and a parked Trabant.

Do Not Refreeze Exhibition Halle cars by Helga Paris

Halle 1984 Photo by Helga Paris

In one photo by Helga Paris, we have what looks like a sports car from the 1950s, next to a Wartburg and a Trabant. In matters automotive, variety wasn’t the spice of life in East Germany

Further street scenes provide a precious document of Halle as it once looked. In fact, most of East Germany and the communist east looked like this. And I can also remember the ever-present smell of two-stroke mix from the 3 cylinder engines.

It is still shocking to see beautiful original half-timbered houses abandoned and practically falling down. How many of them are still there today?

A shop window is almost empty, like the street it looks onto, which is reflected in the glass. Such was the reality of life in East Germany.

Do Not Refreeze Exhibition Halle by Helga Paris

Halle buildings in snow 1984 Photo by Helga Paris

In one wintry image, the snow seems to mask the decay, until you look more closely and see that between the snow-covered roof timbers there is nothing at all, as the roof has fallen in.

If there is beauty in dereliction and decay, then the GDR was the most beautiful country in the world!

I’m reminded here of the paintings and drawings of  Trevor Grimshaw, who found a stark beauty in the townscapes of northern England.

We have now reached the top floor of the Cornerhouse gallery, and Erasmus Schröter’s large format images of street scenes continue the theme of derelict but atmospheric cityscapes, with more of those ubiquitous Trabants and Wartburgs.

Do Not Refreeze Exhibition Dresden by Erasmus Schröter

Dresden 1985 Photo by Erasmus Schröter

It’s a vision that’s often empty of people but it starts to take on a grim fascination the more you stare at it. The photo of Dresden tramlines over cobblestones with a blank wall and peeling paintwork speaks volumes about the economic state of the GDR in its fourth decade of existence. Even if colour film had been used, it wouldn’t have picked out very much, apart from the peeling day-glow orange paint I remember seeing on roadside railings in the East.

These large size photos are of superb quality and are original GDR prints. I wonder how these street scenes look today. And it’s impossible to appreciate the quality and detail unless you come to the exhibition. A web page image cannot do justice to the original

Erasmus Schröter’s infra-red night scenes provide a totally unexpected view of the East and caused a sensation when they were first exhibited in the West. He used an infra-red flash, which is invisible to the human eye. The subjects – including the llama being led into a ballroom – didn’t know they were being photographed. The effect is surreal and humorous.

Llama Leipzig DDR by Erasmus Schröter 1981
Llama Leipzig 1981 by Erasmus Schröter

In the photos of Maria Sewcz (25 years old in 1985) we get a different focus, directed towards details of the now-familiar East Berlin streetscape. Cars feature again prominently and signal the progression of time. We are in the eighties, the final decade of the GDR, though almost no one foresaw it at the time.

Her photo of parked Volvo cars and drivers may present a puzzle to the uninitiated. As a regular visitor to East Berlin, I recognise the location: It’s behind the Palace of the Republic, the ‘Erich’s lamp shop’ building we saw earlier, which also housed the GDR’s rubber-stamp parliament, the Volkskammer. The cars – all Volvos – are the official transport of the Communist elite. By this time they had given up on the Tatras and Zils of earlier decades.

DDR East Berlin Cars M Sewcz 1984
East Berlin 1984 Photo by Maria Sewcz

Maria told me she took this photo surreptitiously with an Olympus compact camera loaded with East German ORWO film. She ran quite a risk in capturing this photo. She had applied to be an official photographer at the event but had been turned down. As a kind of revenge, she took this photo which was to be ‘her’ record of the of the event from which she had been excluded.

Another of her photos is of a plane seen above a building facade. Again, local knowledge allows me to read a meaning into this photo which others might not be aware of. East Berliners saw British and French airliners banking over East Berlin on their final approach to Tegel Airport in the West. The planes were a constant reminder of the world beyond the Berlin Wall and all the exotic travel destinations which people in the east could only dream of. But not for long.

A sequence from the GDR film Solo Sunny, made in 1980, features a longing glance at a British BAC 1-11 flying over East Berlin.

Maria insists that her photos should not be described in any way, not even with a title. Originally this was a way of beating the censor, but this principle is still adhered to.

More Wartburgs, trams and Trabants, shot from the hip in an East Berlin that was about to experience its biggest upheaval in decades, the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989.

A sign of the times is a West German tv crew photographed on a street in East Berlin in mid-1989, which Maria took spontaneously from the hip as she was passing.

The series by Ulrich Wüst depicting statues departs from the main theme, though there are some inescapable icons of Communism, such as the face of Karl Marx.

In the end room, the series by Gundula Schulze-Eldowy (31 in 1985) entitled ‘Berlin on a Dog’s Night’ begins with an unexpectedly frivolous self-portrait of the photographer with an unknown man who has his head under her jumper.

Her landscapes of East Germany and Poland are filled with a chilly beauty. I loved the dusk view of the train at a station with a misty backdrop, but where is this?

Her series of photos of an old lady in stages of decline is shocking, partly because of the subject matter, and partly because we wonder how on earth any photographer could get away with producing images like this in the GDR. Some might see the old lady as a symbol of the decline of the East German state but that might be going a bit too far with the symbolism.

Her portraits of East Germans clothed and unclothed continues a theme of unflinching and unflattering realism, but as before the individuality and dignity of the sitters comes through.

Her series of street photographs seems at first sight to satisfy the dictates of Socialist Realism, but on closer inspection, it is subverted by the eccentricity of the people, some of whom appear to be on the edge of madness and have a surreal ‘Diane Arbus’ quality. It’s a good example of how the photographers were able to be subversive, while the authorities were not perceptive enough – or maybe not intelligent enough – to notice.

DDR East Beriln Mielke by G Schulze 1984

Hoffman, Kulikowski and Mielke 1984 Photo by Gundula Schulze Eldowy

One very striking image sums up the East German regime very well. It’s the photo of Hoffman, Kulikowski and Mielke at the May 1st parade 1984. Mielke was the head of the Stasi from 1957 until 1989. They are indulging in some Soviet-GDR pleasantries on the podium at the foot of which, a stern and comical plainclothes security man peers suspiciously to one side, lips pursed. This seems to sum up the GDR as a state of party functionaries and military big wigs in big Soviet-style hats supported and protected by an army of zealous and petty-minded Stasi agents. This might perhaps have been my choice as a signature image for the exhibition, but I doubt if it would have the pulling power of ‘Kirsten Hopperade’.

The date above the podium is May 1984. Five and a half years later the entire structure of Communist control in East Germany would have collapsed, and soon the big Soviet hats would be on sale as souvenirs in front of the re-opened Brandenburg gate. Few realised how close the end was, least of all Erich Honecker, who predicted the Wall would still be there in ’50 and even 100 years’. I also had no idea of what was around the corner.

Do Not Refreeze takes us on a journey through a lost world, which then as now, has been seriously neglected and overlooked both here in the UK and in West Germany.

The photographs touch on a very wide range of themes and use many different techniques and formats, though colour photography isn’t one of them, and I think the exhibition is all the better for this. East Germany was often described as ‘grau in grau’ or ‘grey in grey’ and so black and white is the ideal medium in which to depict it. In any case, colour film was for most photographers in the East prohibitively expensive.

Anyone who appreciates photography – particularly black and white photography – will enjoy these pictures as they are of world-class quality.

And anyone with any knowledge of the eastern part of Germany whether before the Wall came down or in more recent times should find these images irresistibly fascinating, and of great historical value.

The exhibition was curated by Matthew Shaul, Head of Programming at the University of Hertfordshire Galleries. He told me the idea for the exhibition came to him after seeing some of the work of East German photographers at an exhibition at the Neue Nationalgalerie Berlin in 2003. Though he found the sculptures and paintings mostly little more than historical curios, he was bowled over by the quality and universal appeal of the photography and resolved to bring an exhibition of these photographs to the UK.

After four years and a huge amount of work, ‘Do Not Refreeze’ is the result, and it is fantastic.

Only someone with first-hand experience of Germany could have pulled this exhibition together. With his excellent knowledge of the language and professional awareness of the artistic and cultural scene in both countries, Matthew provides the essential link between the UK and Germany. A German curator would probably have found it difficult to find their way around the British art scene. And no British curator would have been aware of the depth and quality of the East German photographers without being introduced to it in Germany, as Matthew Shaul was.

He is very pleased that the exhibition was taken up so enthusiastically by Manchester’s Cornerhouse, which he regards as the pre-eminent exhibition space in the North West.

If I was still teaching German I would have instructed every student of mine to go to the Cornerhouse and see it.

This is a five-star exhibition of world-class photography and I recommend everyone to go and see it.

After Cornerhouse Manchester, the show is moving to the University of Hertfordshire’s gallery in Hatfield, then Focal Point Southampton and finally the Wolverhampton Art Gallery and Museum.

Admission is free, so there is no excuse whatsoever for not attending! Learn about photography, learn about an important and forgotten world that is part of the history of Europe, go and see ‘Do Not Refreeze Photography Behind the Berlin Wall’ while you can!

Filed Under: Language learning Tagged With: black and white photography, Communist bloc, Cornerhouse Manchester, East German photography, GDR, monochrome photography, photography

Video: The UK and German healthcare systems compared

2020-10-08 By Aidan O'Rourke

I am a coach in languages and I’m keen to explore issues concerning the UK and Germany. This presentation is mostly in English but I also include some examples of German words and phrases to do with healthcare. You can’t talk about healthcare in Germany without using some German.

Following a suggestion from a fellow pro-European campaigner, she was campaigning in favour of the NHS, I decided to look at the question of how the UK’s National Health Service compares to the health system in Germany.

This is just a very brief overview of a complex subject. I’m going to give some personal opinions as well as general information based on my research. There are some statistics as well.

I’ve tried to ensure everything is factually correct, though some information may not be completely accurate and it will go out of date.

Revised version published by Aidan O’Rourke | Sunday the 30th of August, 2020

So which health system is better? The British NHS or the German healthcare system?

Es ist kompliziert! It’s complicated!

OK, so what is the fundamental difference between the UK system and the German system?
The UK’s NHS is owned and run by the state and it’s free at the point of use.

The German system is mostly free at the point of use but it’s paid for through contributions to a health insurance scheme that’s closely regulated by the state.

The money to pay for your healthcare is taken directly out of your salary. The amount appears on your wage slip. This money goes into a health fund – ein Gesundheitsfonds and then into your chosen Krankenkasse or health insurance ‘pot’. In the UK, the money to support the health system is provided by the government, mostly through general taxation.

The NHS was launched in 1948 at what was then called Park Hospital in Urmston near Manchester. Today it’s Trafford General Hospital. A blue plaque commemorates the launch.

British people are proud of their NHS and they often compare it to the US system. They like the fact that it’s free, unlike the American system which relies mostly on private health insurance.

Aneurin Bevan – he was from Wales and that’s a Welsh name – was Labour health minister from 1945 and he is credited as the father of the NHS. There’s a statue of him on Queen Street in the Welsh capital, Cardiff.

The Charité hospital, East Berlin (GDR) 1985.

The UK system is more like the old GDR system and that’s not a criticism. The East German health system provided a good, basic service, though without the expensive equipment found in the West.

After the end of Communism – nach der Wende – the West German system was introduced into the East.
The German system goes back to the late 19th century, when under Otto von Bismarck, Germany pioneered the welfare state.

That system is still in use today. Krankenkassen are non-profit making organisations that are governed by strict regulations.

The biggest state-run Krankenkasse is the Allgemeine Ortskrankenkasse – which you could translate as the general local health insurance organisation. It’s not easy to translate so we’ll just say Krankenkasse.

You’ll find a wide range of private Krankenkassen offering a range of health insurance packages at different contribution levels.

You are required by law to pay into a Krankenkasse. If you earn above a certain amount, you can insure yourself with a private Krankenkasse. Many cater for specific professions.

Birmingham Queen Elizabeth Hospital

Birmingham Queen Elizabeth Hospital

In the UK, the National Health Service is paid for by the government. The amount paid by the government varies depending on which political party is in power.

Statistics indicate that the NHS received considerably more money under Labour governments than the Conservatives, though of course, the Conservatives dispute this.

Uniklinik Köln / Cologne

Cologne Uniklinikum

It’s important to note that the UK also has a private healthcare system which people can gain access to by paying for private health insurance. People also receive private healthcare as a benefit or perk of their job.

So in theory, whether you are in Germany or in the UK, if you have a higher income and/or a better job, you can get better healthcare by paying more.

The NHS has had a funding crisis for many years – German system is not perfect but it’s well-funded.
Due to Brexit, the NHS now has a serious staffing crisis. Many staff have left and fewer people than before are being recruited from the rest of Europe.

Brexit is bad for the NHS for three reasons: The staffing problems, the effects on the NHS of a possible US trade deal and simply the fact that the NHS is paid for through ongoing taxation.

Brexit is costing the UK a huge amount. Less money from taxation means less money for the NHS.
The claim by the Leave campaign that the UK sends £350m a week to the EU and that this money can instead be paid to the NHS was false and deliberately misleading.

Which hospitals are reputed to be the best in the UK and in Germany? I don’t think it’s possible to give a reliable answer to that question, but there are certainly some famous hospitals: in the UK, Guy’s Hospital in London, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham, The Christie in Manchester and more.

In Germany we would think of the Universitätsklinikum Heidelberg, the Charité in Berlin, Asklepios Klinik Barmbek – Hamburg and the Uniklinikum Köln, are all highly regarded. And by the way Klinik in German can refer to a hospital, not just a small health centre, as in English.

So what are the practical differences between UK and German hospitals? To gain an impression, I went for a walk around a few hospitals in the UK and in Germany.

One thing I noticed walking around the Uniklinik in Cologne is that each department or unit functions as an independent practice. For instance I saw a Notfallpraxis – an emergency practice for children and young people.

In the UK most departments and units display the NHS logo. Healthcare services including hospitals, health centres and emergency ambulance services are organised under NHS trusts. An NHS trust is a non-profit making organisation set up to provide healthcare services.

As of April 2020 there are 217 trusts, and they employ around 800,000 of the NHS’s 1.2 million staff, information from Wikipedia.

Many hospitals in Germany are run by religious organisations, such as the Evangelische Kirche, Germany’s Lutheran Protestant church.

Fresenius Medical Care, Stockport NHS Dialysis Unit

Some medical services are provided to the NHS by outside companies, for instance Fresenius, a German-based company that provides dialysis services.

At UK hospitals you’ll see adverts for fundraising – which is often needed to pay for basic hospital equipment, such as scanners.

In Germany you just don’t see this. Pretty much all the main medical services in Germany are fully funded. This is especially true of hospices. St Ann’s Hospice near Manchester receives just over a third of its funding from the NHS. That means it needs to raise around £20,000 every day just to keep the hospice running.

They organise glamorous celebrity dinners, midnight runs and many other events. They also run charity shops, but is it right that a facility providing a basic healthcare service needs to do this to raise money? In Germany hospices are fully funded.

Here are some more differences I found: The emergency ambulances in Germany have a two-tone sound, but in the UK, they have an oscillating tone. The German siren is called the Martinshorn, named after the company that makes it.

In the UK the emergency ambulances are yellow and green and in Germany they’re red, like the trains. In both countries you’ll often see the same basic vehicle, the German-built Mercedes Sprinter.
On the side of the ambulance in the UK, you’ll see the emergency number 999 and you can dial 111 for non-emergency medical issues and advice.

Ambulances in the UK and Germany

In Germany and other mainland European countries, the emergency number for fire brigade and ambulance is 112. The 112 number also works in the UK and on any GSM phone anywhere in the world.
In recent years in the UK, smaller hospitals have closed and their services, including A&E – Accident and Emergency – have transferred to larger single-site hospitals.

At hospitals in Germany, car parking is generally free for a period, then there’s a charge. This is also the case in Britain, though some have very expensive charges, for instance Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport.

Examples of hospital parking charges UK and Germany

If you are a citizen of another EU state visiting Germany, you can receive healthcare on the same basis as German nationals

This is one of the many advantages of EU membership. The cost of any treatment is charged to the home country of the visitor.

You can travel throughout the whole of the EU plus some additional countries, and receive treatment on the same basis as nationals. It’s not necessary to take out medical insurance, as you do when travelling to the United States, for instance.

I once had a bike accident in Germany, and I was given first class treatment at the local hospital. I just showed them my British passport, the bill was charged to the UK. I didn’t have to pay anything.

The loss of this intelligent and cost-effective healthcare arrangement for the UK and its citizens, especially older people living in other parts of Europe, is one of the many dreadful consequences of Brexit.

If you’re from the UK and suffer illness or have an accident in Germany, you will, thanks to Brexit, most likely have to pay for it yourself, or buy travel insurance before you leave.

At least you’ll be able to gain first hand experience of healthcare in Germany and so you’ll be better able to answer the question of which country has the better system, the UK or Germany.
In the course of my research I found an interesting video on the BBC website with some useful information:

Waiting times for operations are shorter in Germany, typically three to four weeks. In England most people have to wait 22 months for orthopaedic operations. Orthopaedic, that’s the branch of medicine that deals with problems of bones or muscles.

  • Germany has three doctors per 1000 population. The UK has two.
  • Germany has three times as many hospital beds compared to the UK.
  • Germany spends 11.7% of its GDP on health, Britain 10%.
  • Most Germans pay 7% of their income for healthcare. Their employer pays the same.

Most people I’ve spoken to who are familiar with the German healthcare system say it offers a higher standard of service.But people in Germany have to pay for their system directly out of their salary. Some pay many hundreds of euros each month. That’s possible because of Germany’s strong economy.

The British healthcare system provides a good service, and though people don’t pay contributions directly towards the health system, the NHS is paid for through taxation and a share of National Insurance contributions.

Despite its current difficulties, the majority of people in Britain are proud of their health service and they appreciate the work done by medical professionals at all levels.

By a large majority they still support the original idea of the NHS, that is, to provide universal healthcare that’s free at the point of use.

So that’s it, a quick, hopefully informative and maybe entertaining overview of a very complex subject, which I hope will arouse your curiosity to find out more.

If you’re interested in learning German, go to www.aidan.co.uk.

If you’re visiting Germany, I wish you gute Reise! and if you’ve visiting the UK, enjoy your trip. And to all EU nationals visiting another EU country, don’t forget to bring your EHIC card!

Here’s the link to the BBC video I found.

Filed Under: AidanEyewitness YouTube channel, Language learning, Sidebar Display Tagged With: British hospitals, das britische Gesundheitswesen, das deutsche Gesundheitswesen, doctors in Germany, German health system, German hospitals, travelling in Germany, UK healthcare

The Bridges over the River Liffey in Dublin

2018-04-01 By Aidan O'Rourke

Hello, my name’s Aidan O’Rourke and in this video we’re going to look at the bridges over the River Liffey in Dublin

1. The West Link bridge – Droichead an Nascbhóthair Thiar carries the M50 motorway over the River Liffey. It’s 42 metres or 130 feet above the river and was completed in 1990. It’s actually a pair of bridges. The second was added in 2003.

2. The Farmleigh Bridge – Droichead Farmleigh built in the 1870s once carried water and electricity across the river.

3. The Anna Livia bridge – Droichead Abhainn na Life is in Chapelizod in the west of Dublin. It’s mentioned in the book ‘Dubliners’ by James Joyce. It was opened in 1753 and widened with walkways in 2011. Anna Livia – Abhann na Life is the personification of the River Liffey.

4. Island Bridge – Droichead na hInse also called Sarah’s Bridge is near the Phoenix Park. The present bridge was built in 1791 and named after Sarah Fane, Countess of Westmorland, wife of the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland. It was renamed Island Bridge in 1922.

5. Seán Heuston Bridge was originally called Kings Bridge and opened in 1828. The nearby station was also named Kingsbridge. In 1941 both were renamed in memory of Sean Heuston, who took part in the Easter Uprising of 1916. My father always referred to the bridge and the station as ‘Kingsbridge’. Today it carries trams over the River Liffey. Dublin’s light rail system is called ‘Luas’, the word in Irish for speed.

6. Frank Sherwin Bridge – Droichead Phroinsias Uí Shearbháin – is next to Heuston Bridge and was built in 1982. It’s named after the Dublin politician Frank Sherwin

The Anna Livia sculpture is in a small park near the river. It used to be located on O’Connell Street. It was designed by Eamonn O’Doherty

7. Rory O’More Bridge – Droichead Ruaraí Uí Mhóra is located near the Guinness Brewery. The present cast iron bridge was opened 1859. It was made in St Helens near Liverpool. Rory O’More was an organiser of the Irish Rebellion of 1641

8. James Joyce Bridge – Droichead James Joyce was completed in 2003 and designed by Santiago Calatrava. James Joyce’s short story ‘The Dead’ is set in a house overlooking the bridge. With its modern design it contrasts strongly with the surrounding buildings.

9. Mellows Bridge – Droichead Uí Mhaoilíosa, opened in 1768 is the oldest bridge in Dublin. It’s named after Liam Mellows, who took part in the Easter Uprising of 1916. He was born in England and spent part of his childhood in Ashton-under-Lyne, near Manchester.

10. Father Mathew Bridge – Droichead an Athar Maitiú was built in 1816 and is on the site of the oldest bridge in Dublin, Dublin Bridge, dating from 1014. In 1938 it was named after Father Mathew Catholic priest and teetotalist reformer.

11. O’Donovan Rossa Bridge – Droichead Uí Dhonnabháin Rosa is next to the Civic Offices of Dublin City Council. It was built in 1816. Its former name was Richmond Bridge and was renamed in 1923 after the Fenian leader O’ Donovan Rossa.

12. Grattan Bridge – Droichead Grattan is also known as Essex Bridge and Capel Street Bridge. It’s named after the politician Henry Grattan and is known for its ornate lamps. In the mid-1700s, the centre of Dublin was here and this was the last bridge before the sea. East of here there were no more bridges. The river was full of sailing ships moored along the quays. Later the centre shifted towards the east.

13. The Millennium Bridge – Droichead na Mílaoise is a pedestrian bridge. It was designed by Howley Harrington Architects and constructed in the town of Carlow. It was opened in 1999.

14. The Ha’penny Bridge – Droichead na Life, originally Wellington Bridge, is an icon of Dublin and one of the most photographed bridges in Europe. It was built in 1816 there was a toll of one half a penny to cross the bridge and so it became known as the Ha’penny Bridge. In later years it was increased and I remember my mother saying it was also called the Penny Ha’penny Bridge. It was renovated in 2001 and new lighting was installed. I think it’s too bright. It ought to appear as it did in 1816. It’s estimated that around 30,000 people cross the Ha’penny Bridge every day and I’ve crossed it many times too.

15. O’Connell Bridge – Droichead Uí Chonaill originally Carlisle Bridge, was built 1794. It was widened and rebuilt in 1882 and renamed O’Connell Bridge after the politician Daniel O’Connell. It’s said the bridge is an exact square but that’s not true. It spans 45 metres or 148 feet across the river and is 50 metres wide or 164 feet wide. The sculpted head represents Anna Livia looking westwards.

16. Rosie Hackett Bridge – Droichead Róise Haicéad was opened on 20 May 2014 and carries trams, buses, taxis, bikes and pedestrians caross the river. Rosie Hackett was a trade union leader.

17. Butt Bridge, in Irish Droichead na Comhdhála or Congress Bridge was built in 1932 It replaced a swivel bridge opened in 1879 and was named after Isaac Butt, lawyer and politician

18. The Loop Line Bridge – Droichead Iarnród na Lúblíne is a railway bridge built in 1891 to link lines to the north and south of the river. From trains crossing the bridge, there are great views of the river but the Loop Line Bridge is controversial because it blocks views of the Custom House.

19. The Talbot Memorial Bridge – Droichead Cuimhneacháin Talbóid was built in 1978 and named after Matt Talbot, who is still revered for his religious devotion and abstinence from alcohol.

20. Sean O’Casey Bridge – Droichead Sheáin Uí Chathasaigh is a pedestrian bridge and opened in 2005. It was designed by architect Cyril O’Neill and named after the famous Irish writer.

21. Samuel Beckett Bridge – Droichead Samuel Beckett was opened in December 2009. It has a striking design – similar to a harp and has become an icon of Dublin and of the entire Irish nation. Samuel Beckett was a famous writer who wrote both in English and French. It’s a swing bridge designed by Santiago Calatrava and built in Rotterdam. The bridge was brought on a raft to Dublin and floated into place.

22. The East Link Bridge, renamed Thomas Clarke Bridge, Droichead Thomáis Uí Chléirigh was opened in 1983. Thomas Clarke was an Irish Republican leader. It’s a toll bridge and is crossed by 14,000 to 17,000 vehicles every day.

The river, the bridges and the quays of Dublin give the city its unique character and are ideal to photograph at any time of the day or night.

Thank you for watching. My name’s Aidan O’Rourke. See you again soon in Dublin.

DUBLIN LIFFEY BRIDGES GERMAN VERSION

Filed Under: Language learning

Review Kraftwerk performing live in Brighton 2017

2017-06-08 By Aidan O'Rourke

Kraftwerk in Brighton 07.06.2017

Kraftwerk in Brighton 07.06.2017

Kraftwerk are a contradiction. They use synthesisers and computers yet their music is full of expressiveness. They deal with complex themes of modernity and technology, yet their lyrics are often slogans or single words, often in multiple languages. On stage the four band members barely tap their feet to the music, and yet their electronic beat is so infectious, it has been the inspiration for dance genres including Hip-Hop, Techno and House.

I saw Kraftwerk at the Brighton Centre on 7 June, 2017. I travelled 260 miles from Manchester by Megabus and Southern Railway, and it was well worth the journey.

There were queues in front of the hall, which overlooks the sea, and after a long wait while the audience took their seats, the lights went down, the electronic beat started, four men walked onto the stage, each wearing a body suit stamped with a wireframe design. They stood behind four electronic musical instruments, futuristic  lecterns, lit up from inside.

On a huge screen behind them, shapes, patterns and words danced in 3D. We viewed them through stereoscopic glasses provided on entry. Each band member operated his electronic control centre – or was it a keyboard – gently tapping a foot or pressing a hand on a button or key.

The show progressed with dazzling and pulsating beats, patterns and slogans: “Eins zwei drei vier fünf sechs sieben acht.” For people, like me, who understand German, it was great. Kraftwerk make German sound cool.

They performed many of their greatest hits, some instrumental, others with words, sung by co-founder Ralf Hütter, who stood on the left. It was clear that he was actually playing the keyboard and singing live. The versions were quite different from the records and had an improvised feel.

I loved their live version of Autobahn with its computer-generated images of a VW Beetle and classic Mercedes driving on an imagined motorway in Germany some time in the seventies.

Radioaktivität has gained new significance since the seventies. The place names flashed up on screen told their own story: “HIROSHIMA – HARRISBURG – TSCHERNOBYL – SELLAFIELD – FUKUSHIMA”.

Each song and its accompanying graphics was an exploration in sound and graphics. Tour de France, Trans Europe Express show Kraftwerk are not just a German but European phenomenon.

The time went quickly and sadly the curtains closed. But there was a surprise in store, I won’t say what it is because it would be a spoiler! Suffice to say it was intriguing, humorous and typically Kraftwerk!

They returned for an encore, and played long, mesmerising tracks with that infectious, groundbreaking electro beat. Abstract waveforms and patterns flashed hypnotically on the screen above. A few people got up and danced at the front enjoying a mini-rave.

Finally each member went off separately, taking the final bow. Ralf Hütter was the last to depart, and that was the end of the Kraftwerk concert, an experience I won’t forget for a long time.

 

Save

Filed Under: Language learning Tagged With: concerts, electronic, German, gigs, Krautrock

Where to visit in Manchester – audio interview

2015-03-07 By Aidan O'Rourke

Manchester United ground Old Trafford

I asked my Mancunian friend Chris Joyce to recommend some places in Manchester for my English language students to visit. He came up with some famous places but he also mentioned some less well-known attractions. Chris speaks with a true Mancunian accent so click play to listen to the recording and listen carefully!

Aidan Where would you take the visitors to our city, Manchester?

Chris: A multitude of places to start with, ah, let me see… First we’ll go to Smithfield market on a Sunday morning, (the) biggest open-air market and second hand selling place in Manchester.

Aidan: Car boot sale.

Chris: Car boot sale. (It) starts at six in the morning and finishes about twelve. I’d also take a couple of them to the Trafford Centre, and to Old Trafford itself, the football ground, the home of the champions, Manchester United.

Where else would I go? I’d take them to Sale Marina, and show them that in such a busy place like this, there are huge stretches of green and water for the sailing, the water skiing and what have you.

And I’d take them to Heaton Park. Again, all this green urban space.

Where else would I take the people to? Let me see. I’d take them to a comedy club to hear the language spoken in the different ways and how the words can be played with to create the humour that people are going to laugh at.

Aidan: What’s the name of the comedy club?

Chris: The Frog and Bucket on Oldham Street. The corner of Oldham Street and Great Ancoats Street. ‘Cause it’s a beautiful city we live in. There, you’ve got the museums. They’re free to go in. Wilmslow Road. Have a walk down the Curry Mile. You’ve got the Northern Quarter with all its different shops, its bars, its different music. You’ve got Central Library, one of the best architectural buildings in Manchester. You’ve got Chinatown itself, which is worth just to go down and see again how different people live.

Chorlton Green Manchester
We have Chorlton village. Go down to the village green there. And it still is actually like a village. And welcome to our city! There y’are, how’s that?

Aidan: That’s brilliant. You mentioned a couple of streets there. What was the one near Levenshulme?

Chris: Oh, The Street With No Name. And that is the actual name of it. There’s a plaque on it. It has no name. It’s never had a name. So it’s officially called The Street With No Name. Also Moon Grove which is about 150 metres long, or 200 metres long. It’s a conservation area, and it’s strictly stayed the way it was built in early Victorian times.

Aidan: With a cobbled street?

Chris: Cobbled street, like oil lanterns outside the house, fantastic place.

Aidan: And just to finish off with, just tell them your name?

Chris: My name’s Chris Joyce, and I live in Manchester and I have done all my life.

Aidan: What part of Manchester did you grow up in?

Chris: I live in Longsight, I live in Victoria Park. I attended St Roberts, St Pius, and the world.

Filed Under: AidanEyewitness YouTube channel, Language learning Tagged With: Audio, Manchester, places to go in Manchester, Soundcloud, tourist attractions, visitor attractions

Tony Wilson interviewing Aidan O’Rourke & guests 2007

2015-02-12 By Aidan O'Rourke

In June 2007 Tony Wilson interviewed Adele Loch Arlene McCarthy and me at the Cornerhouse Manchester. It was on a BBC Radio Manchester programme called Talk of the Town.

Businesswoman Adele Lock founded the Gentry grooming company in Manchester. Arlene McCarthy was at the time Labour Euro MP for the North West. She stood down in 2014.

Adele talked about her experience on the BBC TV programme the apprentice. Arlene McCarthy spoke about her experience of being in politics.

Tony Wilson introduced me as freelance photographer and said that I was perhaps one of the greatest chroniclers of the city, a very flattering introduction and whether or not it’s true, he said it!

After asking about my website address and correcting the spelling of my name, he asked me the question: Do we care about Scotland? In mid-2007, the SNP had had success in elections in Scotland. At the time people were asking the question: Is the union in danger? Six years later people in Scotland voted in a referendum and rejected independence.

Finally Tony Wilson remarked that Glasgow was one of the first cities to start to come alive, to experience a revival in its economy and development. Arlene McCarthy agreed with him and mentioned the European capital of culture title, which has been held by both Glasgow in 1990 and Liverpool in 2008.


Sadly, only just over two months after this interview, Tony Wilson died at the Christie Hospital South Manchester. Like many people in the city I was devastated.

February 2015 marked the closure of the Cornerhouse and the move to the new arts centre HOME, so I decided to republish excerpts from the interview. I believe it’s very important to keep the voice and spirit Tony Wilson alive. I’m proud to have known him as a friend. The square in front of HOME is named Tony Wilson Place.

Filed Under: AidanEyewitness YouTube channel, Language learning

CONTACT

E-mail: info@aidan.co.uk

or you can contact me by sending a message, text or WhatsApp to this number.

phone number spam protected

SELECTED ARTICLES & VIDEOS

Karen McBride “Just A Girl From North Manchester” book review

Video: Manchester Building Boom 2024 seen from train tram & drone

Classic 1963 split-screen VW camper van

Article: Our VW Split Screen Camper Van Nightmare

Video: Building Boom in Manchester 2021

AidanEyewitness video: Building Boom in Manchester 2021

Copyright © 2026 · News Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

On some pages, this website uses cookies. You can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT